When Your Child Falls Apart Over an A-Minus

A missed math problem shouldn't wreck the whole day—but for some kids it does. Hal and Melanie Young on the perfectionist child: the pride, the fear, the answer.Helping Your Perfectionist Child

Melanie’s phone rang. It was their son, away at college, nearly hysterical.

He was going to get an A-minus. If you’re raising a perfectionist child, you know that phone call in your bones.

If you have a child like that — the one who bursts into tears over a missed problem, who won’t try anything unless he already knows he’ll be good at it, who announces he’s “terrible at everything” the moment something is hard — this episode is for you. Hal and Melanie Young take on perfectionism in children, a topic their own Facebook community asked for, and they come at it as parents who have both raised perfectionists and been perfectionists.

Where it comes from. Our faults, Hal says, are often virtues that have gone astray. Wanting to excel is good and biblical — whatever you do, do all to the glory of God. The trouble starts in the slide from excellence into perfectionism. It shows up especially in firstborns, whose parents hovered over every detail, and in gifted kids for whom everything came easily until, one day, it didn’t. Melanie tells her own version: the smartest kid in her school, sent to the North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics, suddenly average — and with no idea who she was anymore.

What “perfect” actually means. When Scripture says be perfect, it isn’t demanding flawlessness; the sense is completeness, maturity. And our righteousness was never ours to produce. Hal walks through Galatians — having begun in the Spirit, are you now being made perfect in the flesh? — and the law as a tutor that leads us to Christ by showing us we cannot.

Why the preteen years are so hard. Brains are remodeling, school gets harder, and — more importantly — this is often when a child tries to meet the standard on his own, before the faith becomes his. So when your child collapses into “I’m so bad, I can’t do anything right,” don’t argue him out of it. Agree, and point him to the gospel: You’re right. None of us can. That’s why God provided a sacrifice.

Two ditches. Perfectionism runs into arrogance on one side — I’ve got my act together, what’s wrong with everyone else — and hopeless guilt on the other. Both are the same error: hope shifted off Jesus and onto our own performance.

And then, the practical half:

  • The weight room. Nobody lifts the heaviest weight on day one. Missing a problem doesn’t mean you’re bad at math; it means you need more reps at that weight. (Works especially well with boys.)
  • Don’t freak out yourself. Perfectionist kids often have perfectionist parents. Watch the teasing, too — Hal brought home a 98 on a Latin exam and his dad joked, “What happened to the other two points?” It was a joke. It landed anyway.
  • Throw them into something they’re bad at. Music, a sport, dance. Melanie made a mortified twelve-year-old go to the homeschool conference dance; he pitched the fit of the century. Years later she watched that same son dance with his bride at his wedding while the whole room went quiet.
  • Teach what quality actually is. Hal’s old job as a quality engineer defined it as conforming to the standard — no more. If the spec says mark it with chalk and cut it with a hatchet, anything beyond that is wasted effort. See also: the neighbor trimming his lawn edge with scissors, and Hal’s third-grade B in handwriting, earned because his cursive loops were too exact to finish on time.
  • Praise the intangibles. The arrogant child who encourages a struggling sibling needs praise for that far more than for the math grade. A C student earning Cs deserves praise; an A student coasting to Cs does not.
  • Watch for the fear underneath. Some perfectionism is pride. A lot of it is fear — and perfect love casts out fear.
  • Even rest is grace. Melanie was required to spend an hour a day in devotions at an inner-city mission and kept falling asleep, until someone told her: He gives to His beloved even in their sleep. Sometimes the godly answer is more sleep, not more effort.

The bottom line, in Melanie’s words: we’re not looking for a checklist before we love our kids — and God isn’t either. Jesus took care of the checklist.

Scriptures mentioned: 1 Corinthians 10:31 · Colossians 3:17 · Matthew 5:48 · James 1:4 · Galatians 3:3, 3:24 · Romans 14 · 1 John 4:18 · Psalm 127:2 · Ephesians 2:8-9

Also mentioned: the Youngs’ Craftsman Crate subscription box (craftsmancrate.com) · the Raising Real Men Community group on Facebook ·

Recorded on the deck in South Carolina — and yes, that’s the dog, who firmly believes no one should be outside without her.

Making Biblical Family Life Practical is hosted by Hal and Melanie Young and is part of the Ultimate Homeschool Podcast Network. This episode is brought to you by CTC Math — ctcmath.com. Find more from Hal and Melanie at HalandMelanie.com.

I Love Homeschooling, But I’ll Tell You Its Flaws

📚 Part of our guide: How to Start Homeschooling

This is one of Homeschooling IRL’s more honest, “hot potato” conversations. Fletch and Kendra interview a guest whose beliefs and choices differ from their own and from many listeners’ — not to endorse, but to model gracious, open dialogue. As they put it, when your identity is anchored in Christ, you can listen to anything without fear.

Special Replay: The Flaws and Benefits of Homeschooling
Homeschooling IRL — Episode 15 | Updated replay for 2026

From the Ultimate Homeschool Podcast Network. This episode is a special replay, updated for 2026. In it, veteran homeschooling parents Fletch and Kendra sit down with homeschool graduate Matthew Mason for one of their most-talked-about conversations — an honest, gracious look at the good, the hard, and the complicated of growing up in the Christian homeschool world.

Sponsor

This episode is brought to you by CTC Math.

Finding a math curriculum that works for your family can be a challenge! With CTCMath, all of your kids from K–12 can learn at their own pace with one family subscription. With a CTCMath membership, you have access to all grades and lessons, which means your children can work at whatever level is best for them — whether they need to catch up, keep up, or move ahead. CTCMath is offering listeners a half-price discount plus a bonus 6 months when you register for a 12-month membership. That means a complete online homeschool math curriculum for all your kids for 18 months! Learn more and claim the offer →

About This Episode

Matthew Mason is a homeschool graduate and a longtime friend of Fletch and Kendra’s family. Homeschooled K–12 and adopted before birth by a pro-life activist mother, Matthew grew up inside what he calls “the bubble” — a reformed, close-knit Christian homeschool community. As a young adult he came out as gay, left that community, and began searching for truth on his own terms. In this candid studio interview, he reflects on what homeschooling gave him and where it fell short.

Together they dig into the questions a lot of homeschool families are afraid to ask: What do we do when a child walks away from the faith or the lifestyle they were raised in? How do we love well when we disagree deeply? And how do we keep our hope anchored in Christ rather than in our parenting?

What Fletch & Kendra Talk About

  • The fear of raising a “prodigal” — and why hope shouldn’t rest in your parenting or results
  • “Hope shifting”: where homeschool parents quietly place their trust
  • Matthew’s story: adoption, the pro-life movement, speech competitions, and leaving the bubble
  • The pros of homeschooling — a tailored, interactive education from the person who knows the child best
  • The flaws — filtered books and music, a single worldview, and kids who never learn to think for themselves
  • How the church and homeschool community can respond with compassion instead of rejection
  • Listening to your kids — really listening — and keeping the lines of communication open

A Listener Note

This is one of Homeschooling IRL’s more honest, “hot potato” conversations. Fletch and Kendra interview a guest whose beliefs and choices differ from their own and from many listeners’ — not to endorse, but to model gracious, open dialogue. As they put it, when your identity is anchored in Christ, you can listen to anything without fear.

More From Homeschooling IRL

If this episode resonated, here are other Homeschooling IRL conversations referenced in it:

  • Love in the House — with Chris Jube, on a large homeschool family that decided to “figure out the love thing.”
  • How to Raise a Pagan Kid in a Christian Home (Ep. 13) — with Barrett & Jennifer Johnson.
  • Homeschooling Will Save Your Children — the two-part series on where our hope for our kids really belongs.
  • How Do I Talk to My Kids About Sex? (Ep. 16) — the follow-up episode, again featuring Barrett & Jennifer Johnson on their book The Talks.

More Shows on the Ultimate Homeschool Podcast Network

There’s a homeschool podcast for everyone on the network. A few you may enjoy:

Browse the full lineup at ultimateradioshow.com.

Connect With Homeschooling IRL

The Homeschooling IRL podcast is a production of the Ultimate Homeschool Podcast Network. This 2026 replay is sponsored by CTC Math.

The Problem of Perfectionism – MBFLP 251


A reader asks, “What can you do about an over-conscientious child?”

C.S. Lewis observed that our sins are often forms of virtues which have gone astray. The apostle Paul wrote to the church at Colossae, “Whatever you do, do it heartily, as to the Lord and not to men, knowing that from the Lord you will receive the reward of the inheritance; for you serve the Lord Jesus Christ.” (Colossians 3:23-24)  We should be pursuing excellence–but it’s very easy to let that pursuit turn into self-righteousness, arrogance, and pride. And it can also drive a person to distraction, depression, and despair, as the reality settles in that we can’t truly reach perfection in our own strength.

So what should we do when we see one of our children … or ourselves … leaning on human effort and achievement instead of faith in Christ? When striving for excellence becomes an unforgiving and ungracious pursuit of the unattainable? When our obedience to God is based on appeasement rather than love?

But doesn’t the Bible speak about perfection?

Yes, it does. Jesus speaks of loving your enemies, a supremely unnatural thing to do, and says if you do this, “you shall be perfect, just as your Father in heaven is perfect.” (Matthew 5:48) While it is true that God is pure and sinless, we aren’t and won’t be until heaven. Yet we can strive after this kind of perfection, which is not sinless but rather, balanced and mature, like James describes: “But let patience [as a result of the testing of your faith] have its perfect work, that you may be perfect and complete, lacking nothing.” (James 1:4)

The sort of perfectionism to beware of has several unhelpful fruits:

  1. Pride – if I think I’ve achieved it, or I think I’m capable
  2. Arrogance – if I look down on others who aren’t trying as hard as I am
  3. Inefficiency – putting too much time and effort into unimportant things
  4. Fear – if I’m not confident I’ll succeed, I don’t want to try
  5. Faithlessness – if I don’t realize how desperately I need Christ
  6. Guilt – if I don’t recognize my inability, any disappointment is my own fault

Really, it’s a form of legalism–hoping to earn God’s favor or dissuade His anger by our own diligence. (continued …)

Can we be over-conscientious? 

It’s good to be careful, watchful, observant. Our hearts are still drawn away from Christ and God’s law, so we need to be on guard against our own sinfulness. Our conscience can be helpful – Paul says in Romans that Gentiles who didn’t know the law of Moses sometimes did the right thing anyway,

when Gentiles, who do not have the law, by nature do the things in the law, these, although not having the law, are a law to themselves, who show the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and between themselves their thoughts accusing or else excusing them (Romans 2:14-15)

But our conscience can be mistaken or confused. Paul wrote the church in Corinth, “I know of nothing against myself, yet I am not justified by this; but He who judges me is the Lord.” (1 Corinthians 4:4) And the apostle John wrote, “If our heart condemns us, God is greater than our heart, and knows all things.” (1 John 3:20)

Romans 14 deals with matters of personal conviction, and Paul says, “Let each be fully convinced in his own mind.” (verse 5) – but we do need to recognize that our conscience needs to be trained by the word of God. And we need to remember that each of us is on life-long road of growth–and we haven’t all reached the same level of maturity yet!

So how should we guide our children in this area?

  1. Our hope and our self-worth are not found in our report cards, our job descriptions, our paychecks, or our prizes — hope and identity come from our relationship to Jesus Christ
  2. Encourage your perfectionist children to try things they might avoid. Encourage your bookworm to learn tennis or dancing. Get your athlete piano lessons or tutoring in French. Help them realize that they can’t excel in everything – and they don’t have to!
  3. Be sure to praise the intangible things. Character doesn’t come with a scorecard, but God is much more concerned with the sort of person we are than the numbers we achieve on the tests.
  4. Help them gauge the real value of quality. If over-exactness makes you late on your homework, you still lose. Sometimes “good enough” is the right answer, and better than “good enough” may actually be a distraction–or worse.
  5. Finally, be sure they understand that “By grace you have been saved through faith, that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God, not of works, lest anyone should boast.” Instead, our obedience to God is not meant to earn His forgiveness or love–it’s our loving response to what He’s already done for us. “For we are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand that we should walk in them.” (Ephesians 2:8-10)

Best of HIRL: I Love Homeschooling, But I’ll Tell You Its Flaws

I Love Homeschooling But I'll Tell You It's Flaws - Homeschooling IRL

On this episode of Homeschooling In Real Life, Fletch and Kendra discuss what it’s like when your homeschool student abandons your family’s faith and lifestyle.

How can this happen in a Christian home where you have created a sheltered homeschool environment? Christian homeschooling is designed to protect our kids. Shouldn’t our children turn out perfect?

To answer that question, we interview a young man who has done that very thing, but here is the best part: after being raised in a rigid environment which he ultimately rejected, he is still a huge proponent of  home education and thinks his mom is one of the best teachers around!

Homeschooling parents, this is an episode you won’t want to miss! We may challenge you to rethink about how you listen to your kids, how to look for and complement their strengths, but mostly we will remind all of us how important it is to just point them to Jesus.


We’d like to thank our Ultimate Homeschool Radio Network sponsor, Like Arrows!

FamilyLife’s first feature film LIKE ARROWS, explores the joys and heartaches of parenting with a story that spans over 50 years. Join us in theaters across America for a special 2 night showing of LIKE ARROWS followed by exclusive after-show content with the film-makers, including celebrated faith-based film-makers Alex and Stephen Kendrick as well as FamilyLife Today’s Dennis and Barbara Rainey and Bob Lepine. You’ll leave encouraged and equipped with powerful next steps to make Christ the center of YOUR parenting.

LIKE ARROWS will be in theaters for two nights only, MAY 1ST and 3RD. To view the trailer and find theater info, visit the link below. If you missed the movie in theatres be sure to check out the Digital, DVD and Blueray versions on the website, LikeArrowsMovie.com

Visit here to learn more.


 

Losing Religion, Finding Grace: A Story of Faith – MBFLP 161

 

What happens when you do everything right and it turns out terribly, awfully wrong? Do you doubt God’s love? Does it shake your faith? Or does it drive you to a closer walk with your Lord and Savior?

This episode, we talk with Kendra Fletcher, the author of the new book (affiliate link!), Lost & Found: Losing Religion, Finding Grace. Kendra and her husband Andy Fletcher (hosts of Homeschooling IRL on this network) have seen both sides of the coin, as God brought them from a cold, rule-based religiosity, to a living faith in a living Jesus day by day. You’ll find it both challenging and encouraging as we talk about this crucially important distinction!

 

Recovering From Legalism – MBFLP 132

Recovering from Legalism V

 

“For by grace you have been saved through faith … not a result of works. lest any man should boast.” The apostle Paul told us that and we all know it … but somehow, we easily turn to legalism when it comes to living out that salvation we received by grace. How can you avoid this? What can you do about it when you discover you’ve slipped into a hopeless, graceless, checklist spiritual life? This episode (recorded at Yosemite National Park!) we talk about learning to listen to God’s Word and His Spirit – and not relying on man-made additions to God’s actual commandments!

This program is brought to you in part by
Schoolhouse Teachers banner-468x60Click here for more information!
Patreon support bar 600x100

Bullied Into Buying – MBFLP 124

Blog - Bullied into Buying - V

Homeschooling allowed us to raise kids that were not peer-dominated, not bullied, not searching for affirmation and validation from every direction. Hooray! The problem is, we parents were not raised that way, and guess what – often we’re the ones with peer group problems. This episode we take an honest look at the way we can be bullied — or be the bullies — when we’re worrying about what other homeschool parents are thinking …

MBFLP – Transitioning to Adulthood with Israel Wayne

MBFLP Transitioning to Adulthood Israel Wayne

 

We all want to raise competent, well-prepared adults as our children grow up. Sometimes our best intentions, though, could be interfering with their growth and may result in something quite different than we hope — even a broken relationship with a twenty-something son or daughter. What’s happening, and more importantly, what can do to avoid it? Join us for this interview with author, speaker, and second-generation homeschooler Israel Wayne, on making the transition to adulthood!

I Love Homeschooling, But I’ll Tell You Its Flaws – HIRL Episode 15

HIRL-Episode-15.jpg

On this episode of Homeschooling In Real Life, Fletch and Kendra discuss what it’s like when your homeschool student abandons your family’s faith and lifestyle.
How can this happen in a Christian home where you have created a sheltered homeschool environment? Christian homeschooling is designed to protect our kids. Shouldn’t our children turn out perfect?
To answer that question, we interview a young man who has done that very thing, but here is the best part: after being raised in a rigid environment which he ultimately rejected, he is still a huge proponent of  home education and thinks his mom is one of the best teachers around!
Homeschooling parents, this is an episode you won’t want to miss! We may challenge you to rethink about how you listen to your kids, how to look for and complement their strengths, but mostly we will remind all of us how important it is to just point them to Jesus.

Join Fletch (from theMangoTimes) and Kendra (from Preschoolers and Peace) podcast every two weeks as they interview guests and talk through some of the goofiness they have experienced in nearly two decades of Homeschooling In Real Life.