School at Home Doesn’t Work (And What To Do Instead)

Thirteen years ago Felice Gerwitz said on tape that she had no idea if this network would work. It did. Episode one of thirteen: why building a school in your dining room falls apart in three weeks, and what to build instead.Thirteen years ago, on the very first episode of this show, Felice Gerwitz said something out loud that most people would have edited out: “When I had this idea to create this radio network, I had no idea if it would even work.”

Within three weeks, the shows launched anyway. HomeschoolingIRL on September 13th. The Homeschool Sanity Show on the 14th. Vintage Homeschool Moms on the 17th. Two more by the 25th. Every one of those episodes is still on this website.

So it worked. And to mark thirteen years, we’re doing thirteen short episodes — thirteen things we’d tell a brand-new homeschool mom.

This is the first one, and it’s the mistake nearly all of us made.

We tried to build a school in the dining room. Desks. A bell schedule. A wall calendar with somebody else’s year printed on it. And it lasts about three weeks — then one Tuesday nobody comes to the table, and you sit down certain you’ve failed.

You haven’t failed at homeschooling. You’ve failed at being a school, which was never the assignment.

In this episode:

  • Why a school is an answer to a problem you don’t actually have — one adult, thirty children, a building, a bus schedule, a fire code
  • How much of what looks like “school” is really crowd management
  • Why copying that form into your house makes everything feel so heavy
  • The difference between structure (good, necessary) and institutional machinery (not yours to carry)

The one question to answer in writing today:

  • what problem are we actually solving?
  • Why you give yourself a one-year trial with a date on the calendar — and why week three is when everybody wants to quit

Timestamps

  • 00:54 — Felice Gerwitz, August 2013, on the first episode of this show
  • 01:50 — The three weeks in September 2013 when the network actually launched
  • 02:14 — Why thirteen short episodes instead of a retrospective
  • 02:47 — The mistake: building a school in the dining room
  • 03:26 — A word from Eden’s Table
  • 04:21 — A school is an answer to a problem you don’t have
  • 05:30 — Structure is good. It just comes from your family.
  • 06:06 — Write down the problem you’re actually solving
  • 06:49 — Give yourself one year, then judge it
  • 07:11 — Why week three is the worst of it
  • 07:59 — Next time: the day is shorter than you think

Go deeper on the network

Before you commit to a year, listen to Should You Consider Homeschooling? — it walks through the decision honestly, including the reasons not to.

It’s our 13th birthday

More than $1,500 in prizes across four October drawings, and a free Sweet Treats resource bundle for everyone who enters. One entry puts you in all four.

👉 Enter the Sweet 13 Giveaway

Our Sweet 13 sponsors

This series is sponsored by Eden’s Table, CTCMath, True North Academy, and the podcasters of the Ultimate Homeschool Podcast Network.

This episode’s sponsor is Eden’s Table — Biblical herbalism for the elementary grades. One plant a week, with science, history, art, reading and handwriting running through it as a single unit study. Open and go, no prep the night before. The first nine weeks are $39 at edeninstitute.health/homeschool.

This episode is sponsored. We only take sponsors we’d point our own families to.

Sweet 13 Bonus: Should You Even Homeschool?

Sweet 13 Vintage Homeschool Moms Podcast bonus episode

Thirteen years ago this network did not exist. There was an idea, a spare room, and a handful of friends from the homeschool conference circuit who said yes.

This bonus episode is the birthday party. One question at a time, every host on the network answers something a real homeschool mom actually asked — and you will hear the show that started it all twice: once at the top, and once at the end.

Felice’s question in this episode: “Should you consider homeschooling?”

It is the question that has never stopped arriving in her inbox, from the mom who is scared and hopeful in equal measure. If it is speaking to someone you know, send them the full episode.

Felice closes the show too, with the part she does not usually say out loud: what it actually cost to keep this thing on the air, and why the podcasters here are unsung heroes.

Also in this episode: Hal and Melanie Young on boys who will not sit still · Dr. Melanie Wilson on why you are already behind · the 7Sisters on the high school transcript · Sue Myers on a fever and a two-year-old · Meryl van der Merwe on teenagers and AI · Meredith Curtis on getting the joy back · Lisa Nehring on life skills before they launch.

🎂 The Sweet 13 Giveaway is open. More than $1,500 in prizes, four drawings across October, and a free party favor for everyone who enters. Enter at ultimateradioshow.com/sweet-13 — October 1 through 29. No purchase necessary, US residents 18+, official rules here.

Presented by Eden’s Table. Use code EDEN13.