What Do I Do When Nothing Is Working?

Stop, and resist the urge to fix everything at once. A bad homeschool year is usually one or two specific problems that have spread, not a general failure of the whole enterprise.

Take a week off first

You cannot diagnose a situation from inside the panic. A week of no formal work costs almost nothing academically and changes what you can see.

Do not spend that week researching new curriculum. That is the panic talking, and it usually leads to spending money on a problem you have not identified.

Write down what is actually wrong

Be specific. Not “everything is a disaster” but “math ends in tears four days a week,” “I have not planned anything since September,” “the toddler makes the morning impossible,” “I am not sleeping.”

Most families find three or four concrete items. Several of them are usually downstream of one.

Fix the one that is causing the others

There is normally a single item generating most of the misery. Handle that one and reassess before touching anything else. Changing five things at once means you learn nothing about what helped.

Cut to the minimum for a month

Math, reading, and reading aloud together. That is a real school day. Everything else can stop for four weeks while things stabilize.

Children do not lose a year over a light month. They do lose things over a year of daily conflict.

Then decide about curriculum

Sometimes the material genuinely is wrong, and switching mid-year is the right call. Make that decision after the week off and the diagnosis, not during the worst of it.

And say it out loud to someone

Most homeschool parents in a bad year believe they are the only one. They are not, by a wide margin. The experienced families you admire have all had a year like this, and most of them will tell you about it if you ask.

Listen to this

• 12 Homeschool Hacks That Changed Everything (Special Replay)
• To The Homeschool Mom Who Feels Like She’s Failing